Shin, Your impression is mistaken. I try to be concise and helpful. Did I provide any incorrect information to you or Amit? Also, I may not be a new traveler to Japan, but I do travel within the country and I help run a website about travel in Japan, so I do humbly consider myself qualified to give some advice.
I would actually like to make our itineraries more useful, so I was asking Amit to elaborate on his exact needs. He said his needs were specific and that the itineraries didn’t meet his requirements, but the initial question and follow up were quite general.
Also, unless Amit is in the country, working llegally, which I assume he is not, he isn’t entitled to a JR pass. Rather a crucial piece of information to emphasize wouldn’t you think?